Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Thomas Mouton's avatar

This is a much-needed and thorough critique of the predominant conversations within the left/progressive groups. After all the built-up momentum it appears it may be wasted on misguided energy directed at attacks on individuals all for "likes and shares". Even though as a whole we are fairly progressive-leaning, I often find deep frustration even within my own profession of architecture and design as we seemed to repeatedly fall short of critiquing the system responsible for all these "systemic issues" they love to talk about . We talk about things like racial and social inequities prevalent in the urban environment/architecture, yet we frame solutions based on the very system expecting different results. Even academia is guilty of this as though collectively we subconsciously embrace Francis fukuyama's declaration of the "end of history" with the triumph of neoliberal capitalism. I see this in every proposal about issues within my own wonderful Crescent City with serious discourse framing these current failures as if they are just temporal flaws as opposed to fundamental characteristics of the prevailing system. Anyway, it was an enjoyable read.

Expand full comment
Tracy's avatar

Excellent essay. It really hits on so many levels. I think it is critical to step back and analyze social issues through the systems lens. I have been frustrated and sickened by the state of the homeless crisis in Portland and the hopelessness that I feel about it improving. It is another systems issue that is more often seen as a "personal failure". Demonizing and "otherizing" humans that are in a profound state of crisis is another way to steer the focus away from the massive systems that fuel and compound inequities.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts